National Historic Landmark · Sag Harbor, New York

First Presbyterian Church

Added to the National Register in 1994, and a National Historic Landmark.

First Presbyterian Church
Photos via Wikimedia Commons

The record

Property typeBuilding
Address44 Union St., Sag Harbor, NY
CountySuffolk County
ListedApr 19, 1994
Listed forArchitecture
Level of significanceNational
Also known as"Old Whaler's Church"
Reference number94001194
ArchitectMinard Lafever
StyleGreek Revival architecture
DesignationsNational Historic Landmark

The nomination form, the document that argues why this place matters, is in the National Archives: Read the nomination ↗

Visiting

Address44 Union St., Sag Harbor, NY
Coordinates40.9972° N, 72.2936° W · Directions ↗
Listing on the Register does not open the door. Unless a museum or park runs it, treat this as private property and see it from the sidewalk.

Explore

Map

Public land around it

Elizabeth Alexandra Morton National Wildlife Refuge ↗National Wildlife Refuge, U.S. Fish and Wildlife ServiceAbout 4 miles away185 acres

Wilderness Atlas publishes a centroid and an acreage for each unit, not a boundary line. Distance here is measured to a circle of the same area drawn around that centroid, so treat it as roughly right rather than surveyed.

Guidebooks to historic places in New York

We earn a small commission if you buy through these links. It does not change what we list.

Titles come from Open Library's catalog, matched by subject heading or by title.

Reference

Questions people ask

When was First Presbyterian Church listed on the National Register?

Apr 19, 1994. It is also a National Historic Landmark, the higher of the two designations.

Source: National Park Service

Who designed First Presbyterian Church?

Minard Lafever, working in the Greek Revival architecture style.

Source: Wikidata

Where is First Presbyterian Church?

44 Union St., Sag Harbor, Suffolk County, New York.

Source: National Park Service

Where is the nomination form for First Presbyterian Church?

The National Archives holds the nomination form, the document that made the case for listing.

Source: National Archives

Sources

Name, location, type and dates come from the National Register office's spreadsheet of listed properties, because the Park Service's spatial data does not carry this listing. The map point comes from Wikidata. Construction date, architect, style, photograph and encyclopedia link come from Wikidata and Wikimedia Commons, matched on reference number 94001194. Nothing here is transcribed by hand. The nomination form and photographs ↗ at NPGallery are the original nomination as filed with the National Park Service, and the form is often the best description of the place.